Scott Boras‘ company might have exploited Dominican Republic talented baseball players by giving them and their families loans and other payments in return for a better chance to represent the players and earn back the money paid out, and more, through the commissions received on their signing bonuses. Scott Boras and his company would stand to make much more money off of the players if they made it to the Majors, earned more than minimum salary, and kept Boras Corp. as their agency for representation.
But what we really care about here is that these disbursements might contravene MLB Players Association Rules and Regulations. If the loans were registered with the union, then the MLBPA would move on. But if Boras Corp. did not first consult with the union regarding these loans, there could be consequences for the company’s prior actions.
As always, my colleague Gabe Feldman, head of the sports law department at Tulane Law School, has some insightful comments on the matter.
“You worry that these agents are gaining ownership over these prospects. And the prospects then feel so indebted to the agents that the prospects feel that they cannot leave the agent for another.”
And I agree. But instead of talking too much about the exploitation of innocent Dominican players, let’s stay focused on the MLBPA Rules and Regulations, which Boras and his team of lawyers should be combing over a few times this holiday weekend.
The MLBPA Regulations Governing Player Agents were amended as of October 1, 2010. Unfortunately, I do not have a good uploaded copy of the old Regulations, which would have been the regulations that Boras Corp. was operating under when it provided any money to Dominican prospects. The new Regs may be found at the end of this post. Pay specific attention to Pages 20 and 21.
These rules state that no money or other thing of value may be provided to a player, or any person related to the player, for the purpose of inducing or encouraging the player to use or continue to use any person’s or firm’s services as a Player Agent, Representative, or Draft Advisor. Read everything that follows that statement and quickly see that this issue could become one of interpretation. My money is on Boras coming out of this unscathed.